Article 2012

A critical time for medical education: The perils of competence-based reform of the curriculum

Advances in Health Sciences Education
Journal · Vol. 17 · Issue 2 · pp. 241-246
Abstract

Rapid expansion in scientific knowledge, changes in medical practice, and greater demands from patients and society necessitate reform of the medical curriculum. In recognition of this, medical educators across the world have recommended the adoption of competence-based education. This is intended to increase the rigour and relevance of the curriculum, move students beyond a focus on the memorisation and regurgitation of scientific facts, and better enable them to understand scientific principles and apply them to the practice of medicine. Experience from 40 years' use of competence-based curricula across the world suggests that the uncritical application of this approach to the medical curriculum may not achieve its intended aims. There are valuable lessons to be learnt from the history of competence-based education. By taking on board these lessons, confronting the pitfalls of this approach, and devising new and creative solutions to the problems inherent in this methodology, medical educators can better achieve their aim of providing a strong foundation for the practice of medicine in the twenty-first century. It is only through such a strategy-rather than the uncritical adoption of this educational approach-that we will have real movement and progress both in competence-based education in general, and in its applications to medicine in particular. © 2010 Springer Science+Business Media B.V.

Keywords

Author Keywords

Competence-based education Curriculum development Curriculum reform medical education Canada United States United Kingdom Curriculum Change Scotland

Index Keywords

Teaching learning attitude to health clinical competence human medical education Health Knowledge, Attitudes, Practice Humans Article curriculum United Kingdom United States Canada Education, Medical methodology Scotland Time Factors Great Britain time
Author Affiliations
Rutgers Health, Newark, NJ, United States
Änderung Consulting, New York, NY, United States
Funding & Acknowledgements
No funding information
References 10 References
1 Competency Based Education and Training A World Perspective, (2025)
2 Ashworth, Peter D., On ‘Competence’, Journal of Further and Higher Education, 14, 2, pp. 3-25, (1990)
3 Scientific Foundations for Future Physicians, (2009)
4 Barber, Philip V., The colleges, Calman, and the new deal, Lancet, 350, 9083, (1997)
5 Education Training and the Future of Work II, (1999)
6 Cave, Ernie, Managerial effectiveness: The identification of need, Management Learning, 24, 2, pp. 122-137, (1993)
7 Re Visiting the Nvq Debate Bad Qualifications Expansive Learning Environments and Prospects for Upskilling Workers, (2007)
8 Statistics of Education Vocational Qualifications in the Uk 2001 02 National Statistics Bulletin Issue 02 03, (2003)
9 Competency Based Training and the Education of Professions is A Happy Marriage Possible, (1991)
10 Erridge, Andrew, The validity and value of national vocational qualifications: The case of purchasing, Vocational Aspect of Education, 46, 2, pp. 139-154, (1994)
Quick Actions
Full Text via DOI
Citation Metrics
73
Times Cited (Scopus)

References 10
Document Identifiers