Article Gold Open Access 2006

Medical students' perceptions in relation to ethnicity and gender: A qualitative study

BMC Medical Education
Journal · Vol. 6 · Art. 17
Abstract

Background: The British medical student population has undergone rapid diversification over the last decades. This study focuses on medical students' views about their experiences in relation to ethnicity and gender during their undergraduate training within the context of the hidden curriculum in one British medical school as part of a wider qualitative research project into undergraduate medical education. Method: We interviewed 36 undergraduate medical students in one British Medical School, across all five years of training using a semi-structured interview schedule. We selected them by random and quota sampling, stratified by sex and ethnicity and used the whole medical school population as a sampling frame. Data analyses involved the identification of common themes, reported by means of illustrative quotations and simple counts. Results: The students provided information about variations patterned by gender in their motivation and influences when deciding to study medicine. Issues in relation to ethnicity were: gaining independence from parents, perceived limitations to career prospects, incompatibility of some religious beliefs with some medical practices and acquired open-mindedness towards students and patients from different ethnic backgrounds. Despite claiming no experiences of gender difference during medical training, female and male students expressed gender stereotypes, e.g. that women bring particularly caring and sympathetic attitudes to medicine, or that surgery requires the physical strength and competitiveness stereotypically associated with men that are likely to support the continuation of gender differentiation in medical careers. Conclusion: The key themes identified in this paper in relation to ethnicity and to gender have important implications for medical educators and for those concerned with professional development. The results suggest a need to open up aspects of these relatively covert elements of student culture to scrutiny and debate and to take an explicitly wider view of the influence of what has sometimes been called the hidden curriculum upon the training of medical professionals and the practice of medicine. © 2006Lempp and Seale; licensee BioMed Central Ltd.

Keywords

Author Keywords

Not provided

Index Keywords

adult female human male medical education Decision making Gender Article interview Vocational education motivation United Kingdom Information medical student career medical school normal human qualitative analysis attitude perception sex difference parent Competition ethnology data analysis medical practice population research muscle strength independence serotype stereotypy
Author Affiliations
Department of Rheumatology, Faculty of Life Sciences & Medicine, London, United Kingdom
School of Social Sciences and Law, Brunel University London, Uxbridge, Middlesex, United Kingdom
Funding & Acknowledgements
No funding information
References 10 References
1 Goldacre, Michael J., Country of training and ethnic origin of UK doctors: Database and survey studies, British Medical Journal, 329, 7466, pp. 597-600, (2004)
2 McManus, Ian Chris, Medical school applications—a critical situation: The supply of medical students may not meet the demands of medical school expansion in the United Kingdom, BMJ, 325, 7368, pp. 786-787, (2002)
3 Racism in Medicine an Agenda for Change, (2001)
4 Making Doctors an Institutional Apprenticeship, (1997)
5 McManus, Chris, Medical careers: Stories of a life, Medical Education, Supplement, 31, SUPPL. 1, pp. 31-35, (1997)
6 Guardian, (2002)
7 McManus, Ian Chris, Medical school applicants from ethnic minority groups: Identifying If and when they are disadvantaged, BMJ, 310, 6978, (1995)
8 Esmail, Aneez, Acceptance into medical school and racial discrimination, BMJ, 310, 6978, (1995)
9 Bligh, John G., More medical students for England, Medical Education, 35, 8, pp. 712-713, (2001)
10 Esmail, Aneez, Discrimination in the discretionary points award scheme: Comparison of white with non-white consultants and men with women, British Medical Journal, 326, 7391, pp. 687-688, (2003)
Quick Actions
Full Text via DOI
Citation Metrics
58
Times Cited (Scopus)

References 10
Document Identifiers