Article Gold Open Access 2025

Challenges in the Transition From Apprenticeships to Higher Education in England, Germany, and Norway

Social Inclusion
Journal · Vol. 13 · Art. 9774
Abstract

The transition from technical and vocational education and training to higher education is particularly challenging for apprenticeship graduates. These challenges are not only bureaucratic or logistical but also reflect deeper systemic inequalities. In many countries, apprenticeship routes at the upper secondary level are disproportionately chosen by disadvantaged groups in relation to class, gender, and/or race. As a result, the limited, time‐consuming, and inconsistently regulated progression pathways in place contribute to the reproduction of social inequality. This article examines how such structural barriers are embedded in three national apprenticeship models in England, Germany, and Norway, where access to apprenticeship qualifications is primarily mediated by the labour market. In England, higher‐level apprenticeship routes combine company‐based learning with part‐time participation in institutional education. In Germany, the parallel or “dual” model integrates school‐based and company‐based training, while Norway’s sequential model structures apprenticeships as successive phases in schools and workplaces. In comparing these models, we conclude that despite differences across transition routes and claims to improve permeability, the divide between vocational and academic education persists across all three systems, thereby reinforcing rather than reducing systemic inequality. © 2025 by the author(s).

Keywords

Author Keywords

Higher education TVET Transition Case study pathways comparative analysis permeability cross‐national

Index Keywords

Author Affiliations
Vocational and Business Education, Osnabrück University, Osnabruck, Niedersachsen, Germany
Institute of Education & Skills, University of Derby, Derby, Derbyshire, United Kingdom
Faculty of Social and Educational Sciences, Norges Teknisk-Naturvitenskapelige Universitet, Trondheim, Trondelag, Norway
Funding & Acknowledgements
No funding information
References 10 References
1 Bildung in Deutschland 2024 Ein Indikatorengestutzter Bericht Mit Einer Analyse Zu Beruflicher Bildung, (2024)
2 Avis, James, Youth transitions, VET and the ‘making’ of class: changing theorisations for changing times?, Research in Post-Compulsory Education, 22, 2, pp. 165-185, (2017)
3 Durchlassigkeit Als Mehrdimensionale Aufgabe Bedingungen Fur Flexible Bildungsubergange, (2016)
4 Barth, Erling, The Scandinavian model-An interpretation, Journal of Public Economics, 117, pp. 60-72, (2014)
5 Hochschulwesen, (2022)
6 Bernhard, Nadine, Supporting needs of vocationally qualified students - Changes towards institutional permeability in Germany ?, Formation Emploi, 146, pp. 129-147, (2019)
7 Boliver, Vikki, Are there distinctive clusters of higher and lower status universities in the UK?, Oxford Review of Education, 41, 5, pp. 608-627, (2015)
8 Diverted Dream Community Colleges and the Promise of Educational Opportunity in America 1900 1985, (1989)
9 Recent Evolution of Apprenticeships Participation and Pathways, (2022)
10 Norway Challenges for the Higher Vocational Education and Training Recognition Scheme, (2024)
Quick Actions
Full Text via DOI
Citation Metrics
0
Times Cited (Scopus)

References 10
Document Identifiers