Article Gold Open Access 2024

Third time is the charm? Adoption and recontextualisation of the German dual model in Mexico

Cogent Education
Journal · Vol. 11 · Issue 1 · Art. 2432104
Abstract

This article examines the adoption and recontextualisation of the German dual apprenticeship model into the Mexican dual apprenticeship model (MMFD in Spanish) through a cultural political economy approach to policy analysis. We analysed the interests, discourse drivers, and resources of involved and absent actors as explanatory variables for MMFD’s institutional configuration. Key actors included federal education agencies, business chambers, and the German International Cooperation Agency, while the Ministry of Labour, the Ministry of the Economy, and trade unions were notably absent. Consequently, MMFD reflects the interests of the governing clique and organised business—both national and international—while excluding the organised working class. The MMFD also framed youth unemployment as a consequence of skills mismatch, overlooking Mexico’s slow-growth economy under neoliberalism since the 1980s. Our qualitative case study reconstructed the policy transfer process using official documents, statistics, and 40 semi-structured interviews analysed within the cultural political economy framework. Triangulating data sources allowed us to reconfirm our findings. Mexico’s adoption of MMFD is a reference for developing countries to extract lessons for policy transfer and adoption. © 2024 The Author(s). Published by Informa UK Limited, trading as Taylor & Francis Group.

Keywords

Author Keywords

policy transfer Education policy adoption of educational models Conalep Dual apprenticeships Education Politics upper-secondary

Index Keywords

Author Affiliations
College of Social Sciences, Glasgow, Scotland, United Kingdom
Tecnológico de Monterrey, Monterrey, NLE, Mexico
Funding & Acknowledgements
Economic and Social Research Council, ESRC
Interview transcripts were analysed through \u2018thematic analysis\u2019, firstly deriving codes and, subsequently, themes that allowed us to propose the drivers of policy adoption. Interviews with key informants were conducted within the framework of an international comparative research project on apprenticeships carried out between 2019 and 2021 and funded by the Global Challenges Research Fund administered by the United Kingdom\u2019s Economic and Social Research Council. The framework study was ethically approved by the respective ethics committees of the funder and the University of Glasgow in accordance with all procedures that apply to research involving human subjects.
References 10 References
1 Mexican Model of Dual Formation, (2017)
2 Estudio Comparativo Las Competencias Necesarias Para La Profesionalizacion Laboral En Mexico, (2020)
3 Los Desafios Que Enfrenta La Formacion De Los Jovenes Para El Trabajo Del Siglo Xxi Las Escuelas De Nivel Medio Superior Y Otras Alternativas, (2018)
4 El Pacto De Dominacion Estado Clase Y Reforma Social En Mexico 1910 1995, (1996)
5 Mexican Model of Dual Formation, (2019)
6 Sobre Nosotros, (2020)
7 Historia, (2014)
8 Policy Adoption of the Mexi can Model of Dual Apprenticeships Business School, (2021)
9 Conalep Experience with Dual Formation, (2017)
10 Informe De Rendicion De Cuentas De Conclusion De La Administracion 2012 2018, (2018)
Quick Actions
Full Text via DOI
Citation Metrics
1
Times Cited (Scopus)

References 10
Document Identifiers